Mentoring as a grassroots effort for integrating refugees – evidence from a randomised field experiment.

Year Published:

Abstract

About 80 million people were displaced worldwide at the end of 2020. To support this highly vulnerable group, in recent years, local bottom-up initiatives proliferated to support refugee integration in hosting communities. This study examines a network intervention for refugees in collaboration with a social start-up whose mission is to match refugees and local volunteers to form friendships. We apply an innovative randomised controlled trial approach with 446 participants integrated into a survey of almost 8000 randomly sampled refugees who moved to Germany between 2013 and 2016. Despite the field experimental study design, statistical imbalances between treatment and control groups arise in the process of enrolment and matching up to the re-interview approximately one year after recruitment, which we address using propensity score weighting. Out of 85 successfully matched individuals, for the 30 refugees with the highest intensity of the intervention we find positive treatment effects on social connectedness, housing satisfaction, and, although less robust, German language proficiency. Thus, a general-purpose mentoring program can promote subjective integration. Effects on objective indicators, such as employment, may only indirectly come about in the longer run.

Citation

Relevant Evidence Summaries

The evidence was reviewed and included in the following summaries: 

What strategies can help newcomers with social integration?

There is strong evidence that peer mentoring and support groups with established immigrants can support social integration of recently arrived newcomers from the same ethnic group. Studies show that peer support groups provide needed social capital and resource sharing to recently arrived refugees and other newcomers.   There is moderate evidence that peer mentoring with […]

About this study

AGE: Adults

DIRECTION OF EVIDENCE: Inconclusive or mixed impact

FULL TEXT AVAILABILITY: Free

GENDER: All

HOST COUNTRY: Germany

HOST COUNTRY INCOME: High Income

INTERVENTION DURATION: 1 year

INTERVENTION: Host community mentoring

OUTCOME AREA: Mentoring

POPULATION: Refugees

REGION OF ORIGIN OF PARTICIPANT(S): Multiple

STRENGTH OF EVIDENCE: Strong

TYPE OF STUDY: Impact evaluation

YEAR PUBLISHED: 2022

More STUDIES